4 Best Dog Shock Collars [Pros and Cons]

Dog Shock Collars in 2021

If you are having problems teaching your dog to stop chasing cars or to stop barking at every single person who passes by, you may want to try a safe and effective shock collar.

If used properly as an obedience training tool, a dog shock collar can do wonders only after the first few times you use it. Your dog will be unrecognizable, and you will feel relieved that it is safe, and that your family, friends and your neighbors are happy as well.

Although the use of shock collars for dogs has become quite a controversial issue, in the US these devices are legal and are recommended by a number of professional dog trainers and vets.

We have spoken to a number of them, in order to find the top 5 best dog shock collars which are completely safe and which can help teach dogs quickly and efficiently.

So, here are our top 5 picks for 2021. Read on to find out more about these incredibly useful training devices, as well as how to use them in order to get the best results.

Shock Collar

SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainer

Most of the dog trainers and experts we spoke with agreed that the SportDOG Brand 425 is definitely one of the best dog shock collars you can buy in 2021.

It is designed to fit comfortably around the dog’s neck and is made of fully waterproof Drytek, and so is the receiver. This means that even if your dog jumps into a pond or river, it will be safe and the collar will still be working safely. The manufacturer claims that the collar can safely be submerged to a depth of 25 feet, so no need to worry if you have a pup that can’t resist a quick swim.

Also, you don’t have to worry if you drop the remote control in a puddle, because it is waterproof and will be just fine.

This shock collar is available in two variants – one with low stimulation levels, which is better suited for gentler and smaller dogs, and a version with higher stimulation for larger and more stubborn canines.

The SportDOG 425 is an excellent option if you want an efficient obedience training tool. It is also very useful for close-range hunting dogs.

Its transmitter is 1.6 oz. and is 5 ¼ x 1 ¾ in size, so you can easily drop it in your pocket or use the lanyard included in the package to hang it somewhere so that your hands are free.

The strap of the collar is 28 inches long and ¾ inches wide, so it will fit dogs with necks up to 23 inches in size.

The collar itself has a built-in antenna, which is much safer than protruding antennas which can cause the dog to get stuck in dense bushes, grasses, and terrains.

The collar can easily be customized so that it fits your dog and suits your specific needs. It has a wide variety of different stimulation modes to pick from. You can choose between tonal, vibrations, 7 modes of momentary, or 7 different modes of continuous stimulation. Adjusting the settings is easy and is done with a single push of a button or by rotating the dial on the small transmitter. This is great because you can quickly adjust the type and intensity of the stimulation at the moment depending on the specific situation.

If you prefer, you can fine-tune the stimulation type and level via the receiver on the collar itself, which is very useful if you are handling several dogs at the same time.

One remote can work with up to 3 separate collars, so if you want, you can purchase two more Add-A-Dog collars, so that you can control 3 pooches simultaneously.

The system has a range of up to 500 yards, which makes it an excellent option for obedience training and close-range hunting.

Both the collar itself and the transmitter are powered by lithium-ion batteries. It is sold with a quick-charge system and a dual lead charger, so you can charge both units simultaneously and quickly. Once fully charged, the collar and transmitter should work for up to 40 to 60 hours.

The transmitter is not only compact, but it is also ergonomic. You can easily turn the stimulation on without even looking down at your hand. You can assign several buttons for the different dogs, in case you are working with more than one. This is a feature that makes the SportDOG 425 a much-preferred shock collar even by professional dog trainers as well as by hunters and other dog owners who have more than one pet.

As a whole, we can strongly recommend this dog shock collar to just about any dog owner or trainer. It can easily be customized to suit any type of dog and to train all kinds of characters – from the gentlest and timid type to the most stubborn ones.

It is waterproof, made of durable materials, and will withstand a lot of training, outdoor adventures, and use.

It is sold with a detailed training DVD, a user’s manual and you will get access to a useful customer care service 6 days a week if you have any questions or need any assistance with the shock collar.

Dogtra 1900S 3/4 Mile Range 1 Dog Training Collar System

The Dogtra 1900S is a top-level dog shock collar with a ¾ mile range which will allow you to cover large distances during obedience training, hunting or when walking your dog. Thanks to the ultra-fast charging system and the split cable, you can fully charge the lithium polymer batteries of the collar and the transmitter in just 2 hours.

Both elements of this dog training system are completely waterproof. The transmitter has a blue LCD display where you can monitor the status of the batteries so you never run out in a critical moment. The display will also show the stimulation level set at the moment, so you know exactly how much stimulation you will be used if necessary. This feature is extra useful if you are out with the dog in low light conditions.

The collar and receiver are slim and can fit comfortably around dogs weighing 35 lbs. or larger. The collar has enhanced, water excelling contact points so that the system will work precisely every time you need it to.

This is a pro range dog shock collar which is commonly used for training K9 working dogs and has options for high output when necessary.

The handheld transmitter has checkered grips on both sides so that you will always have a firm and comfortable grip and be able to use it in the exact right moment without the risk of the unit slipping and you losing control over the dog.

The Dogtra 1900S offers various types and levels of stimulation, including “nick”, “constant” as well as a High-Performance Pager option. The stimulation level can be adjusted very precisely from 0 to 127, so you can suit it to any dog and any situation.

You will also receive a user’s manual, a belt clip for the transmitter, a gear bag, 5/8 inch contact points, and a test light with the system.

If you have two dogs, you can find this system in the 1902S model which allows for the control of two dogs with one transmitter.

Overall, this dog shock collar is definitely one of the most reliable obedience training systems on the market in 2021.

Educator E-Collar


The Educator E-collar is a top pick when it comes to pain-free, humane dog training collars which are offered on the market.  It is an excellent option for those of you who don’t feel comfortable using shock simulation on their dogs, but still, want to get the best results with their training.

The Educator collar is available for one or for two dogs, and in variants with a range of half, one, and ¾ miles, so you can pick the one which will suit your training needs best. Plus, you can choose among several cool color options including camo, orange, black, yellow and Zen.

The Educator E-collar has been designed by expert dog trainers who have kept the interest of both the owner and the dog in mind when creating this humane obedience collar.

It will not provide any painful or frightening shocks, and instead uses low-level blunt stimulation. This type of stimulation while being perfectly painless for the pup is highly efficient for training even the most stubborn and difficult dogs.

The blunt stimulation provided by the e-collar imitates a tap or a touch on the neck area. This is the technique that mother dogs use to teach their puppies, and as such is completely natural to them and doesn’t cause distress or pain.

You can adjust the level of the static stimulation from a level 1 to 100, as well as the boost stimulus from an intensity of 1 to 60.

Both the collar and the remote control are waterproof and shock-resistant, so you don’t have to worry about accidentally damaging either during training or if you happen to drop the remote. The transmitter is designed to float if you drop it in water accidentally.

The remote control itself is ergonomically designed so that you can hold it comfortably and always have access to the buttons even without looking down. It is very easy to use and is pretty straightforward, so even if you are new to using such a device, you won’t have any problem figuring it out quickly. The receiver is just 2 x 1.5 x 1 inches in size and weighs only 2.4 oz. and the transmitter is compact as well – 2.64 x 1.29 inches in size which makes it an excellent option if you want to use it discreetly or if you have small hands.

The system is powered by long-lasting lithium-ion batteries with a life of up to two hours of continuous use.

The Educator E-collar is a suitable choice for all kinds of dogs weighing 5 lbs. or above. It is sold with two different contact points, so you can customize it to fit your dog perfectly no matter its size and coat type.

The humane and pain-free dog training system is made in the US, and you will receive a 2-year full warranty as well as a limited lifetime warranty, so it is definitely worthwhile the money you will pay.

Best Industries TBI Pro Bark Collar

The Best Industries TBI collar is possibly the best option if you are dealing with problems with excessive and unnecessary barking. The collar is fitted with a smart chip and sensor which is activated only when the dog starts barking. It will not switch on if there are noises surrounding the dog, like other barking dogs.

You can set it to automatic mode so that you can easily teach your dog to stop barking even when you are not around. The automatic mode first lets out a warning beep, and only if the dog continues to bark will emit a low-intensity shock. In case the stimulation doesn’t work, the warning alert and the shocks will continue and will gradually increase.

The collar can also be set to vibration and beep mode only if you are not willing to actually administer shocks to the dog.

The collar is easily adjustable and can fit dogs of all sizes – from 6 lbs. to 120 lbs. It is sold with electrodes of different sizes, so that you can pick the ones which work best for your dog, depending on its size, breed and coat type.

It is waterproof so your dog will be safe even if decides to take a swim or if it is pouring outdoors.

You can monitor the intensity of the vibration and the shock via the digital display on the remote transmitter, and you can adjust them at any given moment from 1 to 9.

You will be able to easily spot your dog even at night thanks to the LED lights on the collar itself.

The TBI Pro Bark collar is sold at a very reasonable price and with a 30-day satisfaction guarantee, so if it doesn’t seem to work for your dog, you can return it and get your money back.

This anti-bark collar is an excellent automatic system that will quickly teach your dog to stop any unnecessary and annoying barking. This will help you and your neighbors to relax and live in peace.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of using a dog shock collar for obedience training

Many dog parents have serious reservations when it comes to using a dog shock collar on their beloved pet. In fact, in some countries, the use of these devices has been completely banned and deemed as inhumane. On the other hand, many dog trainers and owners swear on the efficiency and safety of these devices.

The truth is there are various pros as well as cons of using this type of tool.

The Pros of using a dog shock collar

  • Most modern shock collars have improved designs which ensure their safety and also that they do not cause pain to the animal – by using vibrations, sounds or taps rather than shocks
  • The good quality shock collars are highly adjustable, so you can customize the type and level of stimulation precisely depending on your dog and the purpose of using the obedience training tool
  • The results from using a shock collar for training are very quick, especially when used to curb unwanted behavior in dogs
  • These collars are an excellent choice for stubborn dogs who do not respond to other types of training including positive reinforcement
  • Your dog will come back to you without the need of yelling or chasing it around
  • It can actually help save your dog’s life if it suddenly runs off to the street or to another dangerous area
  • Most of these collars have auto shock protection which will switch the stimulation off after a few seconds, and many have an alert indicator to warn you if you are using the shock instead of the vibration or sound stimulation modes
  • There are automatic collars that can curb unwanted barking even without you around
  • Dog shock collars are a much more affordable and time-saving training method than setting up a fence or hiring a professional dog trainer

The cons of using a dog shock collar

  • Using actual shock stimulation can cause mental and physical distress to the dog, especially if it is used over-excessively and incorrectly
  • Misusing a dog shock collar can cause quite serious trauma to a dog – both mental and physical
  • Dog shock collars are meant for training only and not for permanent use or for punishment, which some dog owners fail to understand
  • In some cases, the use of a collar like this can cause the opposite effect and increase the aggression, barking or other unwanted behavior in the dog
  • It won’t provide positive reinforcement, which as you know is the best way to train your dog, so you will need to reward your dog with treats or words instead

In conclusion

It is essential for anyone planning on purchasing and using a dog shock collar to understand the differences between these training devices and to pick the one which is most suitable for the specific dog and the training goals.

When used in accordance with the instructions and at the appropriate stimulation intensity levels and types, a dog shock collar can be one of the best ways to quickly teach a dog to stop behaving inappropriately and to respond to your commands.

Always remember to keep the safety and comfort of your dog first when you use such a device, and make sure that you use it only until you have achieved your training goals and the dog begins responding to your commands or stops the unwanted behavior.

We have picked dog shock collars of all kinds for all types of dogs and needs, so hopefully, you will find the one which suits your specific needs and your dog the best.

Related Articles: